Should Australia Introduce an Internet Traffic Tax?

If there's one thing Aussies love more than bargains, its taxes.

Recently France approved an amendment which proposes a €0.055 per GB tax on internet traffic sent to users. Should Australia introduce a similar bill?

Some arguments for:

  • Big Tech pay their fair share in tax
  • Increased government revenue so we can spend more on the important things like NDIS and interest payments
  • Indirect datacenter tax

Update: On November 3, 2026, the French National Assembly rejected the entire revenue portion of the budget bill 458 to 0, completely wiping the data tax out before it could ever become law. Shocking, totally unexpected, thought the French Socialist Party had this in the bag.

Poll Options

  • 24
    Yes - Introduce an Internet Traffic Tax
  • 461
    No

Comments

Search through all the comments in this post.
  • Recently France approved an amendment

    France is probably not a great place to take as an example, tbh

    • this amendment is now en cours de révision for next weeks riot ordre du jour

    • They have a better work/life balance, better public services, better public transport, better food.

      • Other things the French are better at:

        • making cheese
        • rioting
        • surrendering
      • better work/life balance ?! no you guys in aus have no idea on how lucky you are

        a lot of things have changed in the last few years, including schools, public services are now not as good as before, its difficult to be worse than aus for public transport (or just transport alltogether)

      • better public services

        better schools?

        • No, they have better students who love schools

        • well its a lot cheaper the studies i did cost 24 times more in aus than in france, and even a domestic student is paying several times more than a french one would for uni or tafe. Given some circumstances it would even be subsidised for the french student.

          having said that, for certain studies, ie vetenarian, with europe it can be even cheaper and quicker as french students can study the same for less time and money in other countries like spain or hungary

      • By this metric, the USSR was the ideal, they had better public services, better food, better work/life balance. They also didn't have any problems with misinformation, a land of experts running the show.

        • no they didn't

        • ha ha you're that wrong actually, my dear fellow Commie :)

          but yeah of course there were some other issues in USSR - however a lot of basic things were indeed done fundamentally correct / solid (especially in the 70s or around that time, when it peaked)

          unfortunately the whole set up did not account for human nature etc, so the entire experiment eventually crashed

        • in theory, in reality, the proverb used to be they pretend to pay and we pretend to work
          they did have issues with misinformation and corruption

          i'd say in the western world the problem is that we no longer have experts but celebs running the show, prior to social media we all used to think politicians had some degree of intellect, now that its all out there to see, its as if we elect the worst of us

    • Haha so true, what a hell hole it's turning into. This is what happens when you let lazy, violent criminals into your country because you have a quota to maintain. A data tax against businesses is OK, the problem is that it'll turn into a data tax for everyone which is definitely not OK as only the large companies will be able to afford it and they'll just pass it onto the consumer.

    • It has similar problems to us - they need to tax their way out of debt since cutting spending seems more difficult for the government, as it is with ours

      • you can't successfully tax your way out of excessive spending and waste, all that dopes is cripple the economy. When a government increases revenue then spending increases as well. The mindset of those governing needs to change. France is already one of the highest taxing countries in the world.

  • Should Australia Introduce an Internet Traffic Tax?

    Australia is already doing it; it is called the Australian tax, as Aussie internet is one of the most expensive in the world.

    • Exactly this.
      Besides the Working Class are paying the majority of the collected taxation in Australia, compared to the Ruling Class. We need the pendulum to swing back, and bring balance to the system. Just look at the wealth equality and lifestyle of the Working Class back in 1975 compared to 2025. In 50 Years it has regressed massively.

    • was there a tax on reading comprehension when you went to school?

      this is about taxing businesses for sending data to users. taxing google for serving data to you. not the other way around.

  • Australian Government holding international tech conglomerates accountable?

    And for tax revenue no less?

    C'mon man thats fantasy!

    • Agreed. It's better to keep the tax burden on people instead. How about increasing the GST? How about cutting services for the people? My employer is struggling to afford his yacht's fuel and payments. He doesn't need the benefit of silly things like jobseeker or medicare or a pension.

      The real battlers are struggling to make billions with a weaker economy despite controlling most of the market. They are still trying to increase the prices but it's making Australia too attractive to overseas companies so the government has to step in to prevent foreigners offering better deals.

      Why do people these days have no sympathy for the real battlers of Australia? On that note, I'm glad we stopped taxing the battlers at 75%. Australia was like a commie hellhole back then with tons of government services, including building new housing to support mass immigration due to post-WW2 immigration. Even nationalised Qantas. Hard to make serious profit back then with government in the way of fat hard-earned profits. Boots have never been more delicious these days.

      • Mine was more a comment on weaknesss of successive government to properly tax large companies - or actually hold them accountable - not that we should continue to tax and squeeze middle classes at disproportionate rates.

        I agree with your sentiment although your analogy is a touch melodomatic at times.

        I give you 6 golden akubras out of 10.

        • My comment was the same too.

          In 1900, the income share was heavily top 10% and bottom 50%'s income share very small. Crazy amounts of inequity back then. But that reversed over time, and despite two WW, bottom 50% income share went up while top 10% went down. I believe it was largely thanks to unions who wanted a fair go. It was actually becoming more equitable.

          That is until the workers/unions got betrayed by governments in 80s/90s. Since then, both old parties have suppressed wages in one way or another. The top 10%/bottom 50% share rate have regressed to WW2 era so far and is still regressing. If you find yourself struggling to earn a decent income but occasionally see some top 10% being extremely comfortable, that is really because they are making money than ever.

          • @orangetrain:

            despite two WW

            more like because two WW.

            there was a similar income increase for peasants after the plague (1347–1351)

            30%-60% less workers caused higher wages.

  • It will just be passed on to the consumer, and no doubt the supposed targets of the tax will add on their own little processing fee for the plebs.

    • lol good point - we will be effectively paying for spam!

  • France is almost a failed state, and you want to copy their example?

  • This post is utterly absurd 🤦‍♂️

  • So you're telling me if I stream a 100 GB movie I need to pay almost 6 dollars in tax? Are you completely nuts? Go away already.
    Internet is already extremely expensive in Australian, one of the most expensive in the world. If anything, data should become cheaper not more expensive

      • and where is that $6 going to come from?

        • Share holder pockets & CEO pay

          • @arkie0: 😂😂😂😂😂😂

            Oh bless…

          • @arkie0: Dear lord, this helps pushing me leaning toward, maybe not everyone should vote, slightly .

            Edit: I take that back, I am convinced this is a troll, well done.

            • @xslasherzz: idealist or philosophical troll, hard to tell

          • @arkie0: unfortunately, it would not.

      • I looked, and in France they would make Netflix and other content providers pay for this tax. Which is absolutely laughable because this will obviously increase the price of subscriptions and push more people towards piracy. And who they're going to charge when you download from torrent? And what if I use Netflix with my VPN on? No way for them to know where my data comes from.
        Honestly, the French legislators who put forward this proposal are an absolute bunch of morons who have no idea how internet works.

  • Australia doesn’t have a tax take problem. We have a government spending problem

    • We have a structural deficit problem in the budget. Coalition during the good times got the middle class & retirees addicted to welfare/rebates, and now any policies or proposals to revisit taxation is met with dismay & rage. No doubt NDIS spend has grown much faster than anticipated and it's a service that needs a thorough review too.

      I've said it before, Australians say they want tax reform and spending cuts but don't want to pay for it or be impacted themselves. As Keating said, always back self interest, at least you know it's trying.

      • The people benefiting from income tax cuts are generally not the ones benefiting from all the hand outs.

  • Big Tech pay their fair share in tax

    Who do you think is going to end up paying for this?

      • They will just bump prices up for Australian customers.

        • Remember the good old days when Adobe CS was like quadruple the price in Australia vs the US and people would acquire versions on CD and…

          • @Benoffie: Burn baby burn.

            How are you doing that with AI subscriptions?
            Just acquire a data centre and run it locally?

        • And If we had to pay to use Facebook/IG I think it'll probably a good thing tbh.

          • @cloudy: You're thinking too much like a passive consumer.

            Think like a small business that relies on SEO and Meta Business Suite.

            Now think about the incoming AI marketing costs.

            Now think of this BS against a technical recession and further economic downturn.

            🤦‍♀️

        • Not just that they’ll also figure out a way to minimize paying said tax

  • According to Australian Bureau of Statistics, federal government tax revenue in the past has been

    • FY2016: $370.3 billion
    • FY2025: $675.2 billion

    Even accounting for inflation, increase of population, etc, it's still a big jump. I don't think "how to increase government revenue" should be the biggest concern because it has already increased a lot over the years. How to reduce the government debt on the other hand…

    But yeah, there might be ways to tax the big tech and multi-nationals, without disadvantaging the general public. However taxing the egress from companies would mean that (1) the cost will go back to all the Internet users, or (2) they will leave Australia (eg the News Media Bargain Code).

    And why use France as an example? Don't they already have enough civil unrest? Imagine the outrage when everything they consume on the Internet now costs money, or simply disappears.

    • And why use France as an example?

      They are similar to us in many ways, high public spending with difficulty reigning in that spending. Similar public sector size. High immigration. We have much lower debt to GDP but at the rate we're going we'd be in France's position. If they have a good solution we could copy it.

      The details of the tax need to be nailed down but in principle it could add +$20B

  • This is the stupidiest thing I have heard.

    Do you want to then be taxed on how many kilometers you drive?

    • Do you want to then be taxed on how many kilometers you drive?

      Only if it replaces standard rego.

    • More stupid than like a road user charge on EVs in 2027 starting in NSW - there a one introduced in Victoria passed into law but then challenged at the courts where it was removed. High probability there will be a federal equivalent since EVs are no longer paying the fuel excise (+GST on top).

  • LOL

  • On the top NBN plans of 2 Gbps

    2 Gbps = 250 MB/s
    per hour = 900 GB
    tax = €0.055 per GB

    €49.50 per hour, which in AUD is $79.16 per hour lol

    • Don't worry if big tech introduces a surcharge on usage… we'll just have the RBA or government ban usage surcharges, then from the day after your morning download could be cheaper - the price you see will be the price you pay.

  • That bill in France has gone to their upper house for more debate, so this is not law in France.

  • As if our internet isn't expensive enough

  • Ok, so back in the day when you had to pay per hour and per MB, Australians took to the high seas and created some of the most formidable anti-payment networks known to man.

    It's the reason why the system couldn't hold both limitations. MB limits expanded then collapsed first, and about half way through that, hours also expanded, collapsed and became monthly etc

    To answer the question - any semi educated economist ought to know that more taxes don't equal more revenue.

    Australia is not the country to try such a ludicrous idea.

    • any semi educated economist ought to know that more taxes don't equal more revenue.

      Right but we're talking about the government introducing taxes

  • It violates net neutrality, the fundamental principle of free carriage of information that everyone involved in internet infrastructure broadly abides by. And the proposed law doesn't deal with the wealth and influence that companies like Netflix amass, taxing data transfers is misguided, should just tax the wealth that companies like Netflix amass instead.

    • It violates net neutrality

      I'm sure France is also signed up to any conventions on net neutrality given they're part of the EU and follow EU principles

      should just tax the wealth that companies like Netflix

      I think they're trying to introduce this to get around profit shifting, you can shift profits but you can't shift data usage

  • The only internet rubbish we should tax is ai slop.

    • It could potentially make tiktok scrolling more expensive

  • Can you name one thing that the government funds that isn't a massive blowout and essentially just fraud. Sure, we need a government to organise our society, but they are a giant money wasting machine. Imagine if you needed your lawn mowed, if you get a contractor, they would do it for $120. If you got the government to do it, it would be $1200 and they would only mow half, then they would demand more money to finish it off! Why do we need to give them any more power, if anything they should be removed from health care, the NDIS is a joke and those who actually need it are not getting enough as the government just give it to anyone who cries, I know people rorting the system, as it's just open to abuse.

    • Healthcare. Comparison to USA, all private, which means citizens pay approximately 2x as much for healthcare as we do. https://grattan.edu.au/news/more-expensive-but-less-effectiv…

      • If you want to get anything seen to that isn't cancer these days, be prepared for a 12m+ wait. It's not the same as it used to be.

    • PBS is funded quite reasonably

      Public transport as well

      Medicare is objectively great value

      NDIS is a rort but it's because its setup as a government funded private industry… a distorted bastardised neo-liberal hellhole. It should be similar to Medicare where public carers are organised and funded by the government directly…

    • I know people rorting the system, as it's just open to abuse.

      How long ago did you report these people? Which method did you use.

      NDIS, How to report fraud

  • We should make a basic economics course mandatory before being allowed to post online.

    • Good idea we could get the Government to introduce an online posting licence, you need to pass pre reqs such as econ 101 - then charge fees for that license + an annual cost

      Roughly 21 million online users * $1000 one-time fee + $100-$500 yearly (with tiers) = easily +$1B revenue assuming 100% buy in adoption since posting online is essential

      • YES! Let's not stop until 100% of the population has a job in the civil service or is otherwise taken care of by the NDIS.

  • No, the French are not going to introduce a data tax. It was a political stunt vote by a minor party at night.

    And no, we're not going to implement something so daft here.

    • It was raised by the socialists and greens, so fair chance it could be raised for discussion here as well

      The concept of taxing big tech sells well so we might get a similar proposal

  • If we taxed corporations properly we wouldn't have to come up with bs taxes like an internet tax.

  • No because it'll be passed onto us plebs somehow

  • Definitely not. So when the kids update their Fortnite (guessing about 50gb) it'll cost me $2.75 per device in tax?! Or $11 to download the new GTA VI? No way!

    • We could double the tax if the traffic is from gaming servers, depends on the game… the government could make an approved game list and a double cost list

  • tax those nigeria scammers lol
    but not my inheritance I have 1 million coming from long lost uncle

    • Can I love you long time :-))

      • i likie you very muchie

  • breathing tax next? Wait don't give Albo any ideas

  • Free youtube tier soon to be delivering 4K streams with 56kbps.

  • Most idiotic proposal I heard in a long time. What next? Let's tax the breathing with a progressive rate based on heart beat rate (after mandating everyone to wear smart watches, which would be a good use of these data centres being build everywhere now).

  • for the internet connection speeds in Aus there should be penalty not tariffs!

  • I suggest they introduce a personal air tax for all that clean air we are breathing in and all that polluted air with CO2 we are breathing out

    • Indirectly they tried to do this with carbon pricing, you never know it might return

      • What happened with carbon pricing? I was hearing we will be boiling under the sun, many countries will go under the oceans, etc etc

        It still seems like nothing has happened so far

        • Was removed by Abbot way back, same concept as this topic - the argument was carbon pricing just made everything more expensive, and the cost shifted back onto the consumer

          Now carbon pricing is optional, like how you tick the green option/offset on airfares or gas/electricity and pay a bit more. Can't find detailed information on how many people choose it but I'm reading between 1-6% in Australia.

        • This page sums up carbon pricing in Australia https://greens.org.au/explainers/cprs

          Or if you don't like the source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_pricing_in_Australia

    • We should tax every internet comment too

  • Is this a serious question or can I just flag this as trolling?

    • The French socialists/greens would not raise such a bill as a joke. You may think greens are a troll party but no they are 100% serious.

Login or Join to leave a comment