Need Help - Minimizing Bond Deduction - The OzBargain Way

Hi all,

Just need some community ozbargain advice.
At the end of my tenancy, my agent picked up on a small chip in the granite kitchen benchtop that was not present in the pre-inspection report, and I have no way of getting out of paying it out of my bond.

According to the agent, she has yet to obtain a quote, but a similar benchtop chip costed $385 just recently, and she mentions the owner is happy to accept $250 given the age of the benchtop/depreciation.

I took a photo of the chip and received a quote within 5minutes after sending it, and was quoted $275.

The issue is - chances are the landlord is just going to pocket the $250 and not fix the chip. I want minimize the amount of money the landlord received, rather than the amount I pay (probably not an ozbargain spirit).

My plan was to show them the quote, and counteroffer the following 2 options:
1. Deduct $250 from my bond as long as they show me proof that >$250 was paid to a company which fixed it. (This option will mean the landlord doesn't get a cent, but gets a fixed benchtop, which is not of any value to him as it is small)
2. Deduct $100 from my bond, and that is it. (This will mean the landlord will pocket $100, and I save $150)

I don't mind spending the extra money, I just don't want the landlord to pocket anymore than necessary. What are some of the ozbargainer thoughts? Is this a good counterproposal? Should I offer even less for option 2? (Say, $50?)

Cheers~ :)

Comments

  • +2

    The landlord is within his rights to withhold whatever it costs to return his house to its condition before you moved in. He also dosen't have to show proof that he actually repaired it. Pay the cost and move on.

  • Option 2. Your landlord gets it you're lowballing him and says stuff it you have it fixed. And you may get a bad renter mark

  • +1

    You must pay for any non "wear and tear" damage.
    You do have the right to challenge any quote but in your case your LL is letting you off for less than your own quote.
    Take the offer and run.
    The LL can do whatever he likes with the money.

  • +3

    If you can bring someone to fix it for $250 end of story!
    You will be happy that the landlord didn't pocket any money
    And he will be happy everything good in his house/unit.

    • +1

      Just make sure that whoever you get to do the job does it right.
      If its a botch job then you could be paying for the repair plus the LL.

  • Hi all, thanks very much for your help. I guess lowballing isn't a good idea, I'll offer to pay for my quite minus depreciation. Cheers :)

Login or Join to leave a comment