Solar Installer Went Bust, Inverter Manufacturer Says It Wasn't Installed Properly and Denied My RMA after Shipping to NZ

Hi, looking for some advice.

I had a solar system installed in May 2011 through the Goldfields Solar Hub Project. A month ago my inverter stopped working so I investigated getting it repaired or replaced and also if it was still covered by any warranty policy. The Victorian branch of the installer, Braemac Energy, does not exist anymore*, but the South Australian branch were able to provide me details of the manufacturers warranty, which is valid for 5 years (until May 2016).

I had to get the inverted inspected by someone locally (At my expense) to get a reading of the voltage going in and out of it to prove that the it was the inverter that was faulty. They took photos of the reading on their multimeter, which I sent to Braemac Energy in SA. They were able to open an RMA for me with the manufacturer, enasolar, who are based in NZ. I then had to ship the inverter to NZ at my expense (over $150).

After waiting for it to arrive and clear customs, I received an email saying they were denying my RMA due to some glue being used to secure the inverter to the wall (in addition to the 6 bolts normally used). The glue caused a small piece of brick work to become stuck to the back of the inverter (neither the local solar electrician nor myself were able to remove it, and I had to ship it to NZ wit the piece of brick still attached). Below is the email I received from enasolar's Sales Administrator:

Hi [MY NAME],

If you look at our warranty on page 2 it states that:

The warranty does not apply if, in the judgement of EnaSolar, the product fails due to:
• Damage from shipment or storage
Alterations or repair which may affect the reliability of operation
Force Majeure/Sustained damage by power surges or electrical storms
• Handling or cleaning
• Incorrect installation (as per the installation manual)
• Accident
• Relocation of the product after its first installation
• Abuse, misuse or used/maintained in a manner not conforming to product manual instructions
• Any attempt to modify, make changes or unauthorised repair
• Any serial number having been removed or defaced
• Insufficient ventilation
Cosmetic shortcomings which do not affect the inverter operation

They glue that caused the brick to also come off the wall is a modification not in accordance of our installation standards and the force used to remove this may have impacted the components inside >the inverter/wall mount and caused damage that we are unaware of.

Because of this we cannot repair/replace under warranty.

I do apologies, as I am only following our policy.

Does anyone have any similar experiences or advice as to where I can go from here? I'm disappointed about being out the electrician + shipping without anything to show for it any my broken inverter stranded in NZ.

  • Although there is a Braemac of some kind in Vic, they don't do any solar work at all. I assume they are some kind of franchise but I'm not 100% convinced that they're not trying to dodge responsibility.

Comments

  • Sounds like their trying to weasel out of providing you with a replacements/repair. You could point out that it failed before it was pulled of the wall, but I guess they're saying that there is other damage caused by the forced removal that voids the warranty and ask them how it affected the inverter. Maybe try Fair Trading department in your state or in NZ though I'm not sure how that would work.

    It's costing you money while it's not connected, so maybe pay for a replacement and sell the other off if you are successful in getting a resolution for a replacement.

  • This is tough, I had my solar system installed back when Krudd subsidized the system so much it was free. I saw a lot of solar start ups milk the govt coffers and then when the party was over they are all de registered now. And no one wants to pick up any warranty tabs is the truth.

    I personally think its best just to either try to fix what u have out of ur own pocket, or just buy a new inverter. I've basically consider my warranty useless.

  • +1

    I think you have been treated unfairly, but I don't know if you have any practical avenues for further appeal.
    I suppose reading stuff at:
    http://www.consumerprotection.govt.nz/
    or here:
    https://www.consumer.org.nz/articles/consumer-guarantees-act
    But I think the NZ angle will likely end up at the Disputes Tribunal, which like other small claims venues requires you to turn up in person - not as useful.

    So I would pursue somebody in Australia. Your local consumer rights give you redress over the retailer, or the importer/manufacturer. Since Braemac Energy still exists in SA and (Global HQ) in Sydney, they might be my target.
    I might also pursue Braemac, http://www.braemac.com.au/ who bill themselves as "Braemac is Australia's largest Electronic Component distributor, with offices throughout Australia, New Zealand, Asia, USA and Europe." I bet, if you looked into who got regulatory approvals etc. for the inverter, it would have been Braemac that did the actual importation.

    So it may be an avenue to write to their CEO, registered mail, with a letter stating your case, and that you will pursuing them directly as acting on the advice of their SA energy franchisee didn't get a reasonable outcome.

    I think you may have caused yourself a bit of a disservice by shipping to NZ, as not having the inverter will water down your claim, but the NZ folk may end up helping if they can confirm you did the checks etc. before you shipped it.

    If you make yourself enough of a pain, they might help you out regardless.

    Finally, I'd note that you can buy a cheap and cheerful new 1.5kW inverter on ebay for under $200, so consider if further pursuit and expense is worth your time.

Login or Join to leave a comment