Another Air Safety Investigation for AirAsia

Air safety expert says think twice before booking with budget airlines. Pilot asks passengers "to pray"!

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-26/aviation-expert-urg…

Do you think budget airlines such as AirAsia are less safe?

Related Stores

AirAsia
AirAsia

Comments

  • +1

    "If the difference in the fare was $200, is my life worth $200?"

    This man clearly has not been on this website before. If he had he'd be able to learn skydiving using a free Udemy course, negating the risk of the low fare carrier and that'd be to save 5 bucks, what's this 200 nonsense? :D

    Do you think budget airlines such as AirAsia are less safe?

    Supposedly they all pass the same certification. Flight sims every 6 months and checking engine etc. Australian's fly … a lot. Some time ago the third busiest air corridor in the world was Melbourne - Sydney for example. Yet I don't think there's been a major airline accident in a long time, correct me if I'm wrong. The USA is not so fortunate.

    • +1

      I've spent more than a few years working with aerospace multinationals and have a bit of an inside appreciation on how different countries approach aircraft maintenance.. I have no problems getting on AirAsia planes. I'm always a little nervous about flying on US airlines though.

      If anything, the Asian view to seniority was always a bigger problem than maintenance… The crews were always less willing to call out a captain's mistake… Not so much a case of grinding the threads out of screwjack nuts because they were too cheap to change the grease more often than the legal minimum.

  • Need to wait and see what the cause was - whether AA's fault or something external.

    AirAsia is almost like a franchise in that AirAsia X is not Air Asia Indonesia as such. One only has to look at Indonesia's airline crash record to see why they should be avoided. I'd fly with X but not Indonesia.

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/destinations/asia/indonesi…

    Even the worst airlines though are still miles better safety than driving. People don't pay attention, don't indicate, drive drunk or affected by lack of sleep, drugs etc.

    • the telegraph is just slightly better than clickbait

      • Indonesian airlines are trash. An article is easier for people to read then linking them to all the accidents they've had in the past few decades along with bans.

  • I was noticing the same thing. There's been a lot of bad news coming from Asian airlines lately. And it's not exactly a stretch to say the safety systems and training and maintenance levels are lesser compared to here

  • Can't generalise by budget or non-budget. Rather you should look at the overall rating. Some of the best and the worst have been seen in deals on OzBargain, e.g. Pegasus for a bad airline. AA is relatively benign compared to the ones at the bottom.

    http://www.traveller.com.au/airline-safety-worlds-safest-air…

  • if the air asia plane had crashed then at least they'd be first to the crash site.

    • But I'm sure they would have charged a crash fee, buried in the fine print that nobody reads

      • Maybe their booking default travel insurance that is tricky to click out of, would finally come in handy :)

  • +1

    Air Safety Expert, or idiot? What sort of expert jumps to conclusions when an investigation hasn't yet been completed? Who knows the cause, maybe a bird struck the engine.
    And what is more important … that the pilot asked passengers to pray, or that he landed the thing without even an injury? The latter doesn't seem to rate a mention in the article.
    Once again, the media preys upon the fear of people, referring back to a crash from 3 years ago. How many millions of passengers have successfully flown the airline since then? It is many magnitudes safer than road travel.

    • +1

      Seems like anyone who is willing to talk to the press is automatically labelled as an "expert" of some sort.

      This guy probably just folded paper aeroplanes at school.

  • +1

    We are repeatedly told that planes can fly & land on one engine. And so the thing that disturbed me the most about this event, was the pilot's lack of confidence. Being told to pray is enough to cause a stampede.

    • Maybe the prayers works, who knows?

    • Asking people to pray is probably more a cultural norm than anything else.

    • Didn't look like much of a stampede to me. In fact, looking at the video in the linked article shows the two guys smiling and laughing.

      • I stand corrected. No one was panicking and everyone was having a ball!

Login or Join to leave a comment