Coinbase Actually May Actually Be Better Value?

So, the "value" of Bitcoin continues to climb. Still kicking myself for not buying years ago, but I felt it was all a bit dodgy (crime blah blah blah) so stayed away. Sigh.

Anyhow, sometimes I hear something that is stated as a fact and I like to double check rather than accept at face value. Point in question - just did a quick comparison of local exchanges and coinbase.

I've heard a lot about how coinbase is easy to use but expensive. I wanted to make sure this actually was the case because the price of bitcoin is generally lower on the bigger international exchanges. As of 11:37am today one bitcoin was selling for an average of $17,328 (Cointree: $17,288 - btcmarkets: $17,248 - Coinspot: $17,450). On Coinbase, it was AUD$15,624. That's a 10% difference which is pretty significant, and I thought could actually balance out the extra fees they charge.

So let's do a comparison with btcmarkets (which was the cheapest local market, and seems to have a good rep on ozbargain) and coinbase (also good rep, but claimed to be expensive).

btcmarkets charge 0.85% for trades up to $500
coinbase charge a variable fee, but the most they charge is 3.99%. Initial knee jerk reaction is wow - that is expensive.

Math time. If you bought $300 worth of bitcoin you would get:
btcmarkets: $300 less $2.55 (fee) @ $17,248/coin = 0.17245 BTC
coinbase: $300 less $11.97 (fee) @ $15,624/coin = 0.18435 BTC
That's a difference of 0.0119 BTC or around $20 worth of bitcoin

Happy to be proven wrong, but I calculate (as of today) even with the insanely high fees you will end up with more bitcoin via coinbase whether you're buying $10 or $10,000 worth of bitcoin. Obviously this will all change as the price of bitcoin changes, but thought it was interesting!

Poll Options

  • 2
    OMG - coinbase IS actually better
  • 2
    You're insane - btcmarkets is better
  • 4
    I'm putting everything on black
  • 13
    What's a bitcoin?

Related Stores

Coinbase
Coinbase

Comments

  • +1

    LOL…

  • +1

    I use coinspot, it's a bit of a pain to setup, but easy to use.
    My money is on Ethereum for higher ROI, along with Stellar, IOTA, Litecoin and Siacoin (I bought 10000 Siacoin, if it crashes I owuldn't lose much, but if it goes to even just $10 I'd be pretty happy)

    • +1

      IOTA is killing it at the moment. I got in at 80 cents each. Now it's a tickle under $7

      HODL my friend!

    • Coinspot currently $18,233 and coinbase now $16,105 (dear god, are people insane?). POLi payments have no fee (good) and buying coins cost between 2% and 3% depending on the coin (ouch).

      So, assuming you deposit using POLi and only have to pay the minimum 2% to buy bitcoin, then $300 will get you 0.01612 bitcoin via Coinspot. Same amount via Coinbase will get you 0.01788 bitcoin (all after fees). So about $30 more bitcoin if you use Coinbase.

      Agree about Etherium. I am fairly certain that at some point Bitcoin will come down in flames. It might not happen for a while though - I'm waiting to hear normal non-geek people talking about buying bitcoin first, then I'll know the end will be soon. When it crashes, it will at the same time severely impact on the value of other coins (including Etherium) but once the dust settles crypto currency like Etherium will be in the front seat for the recovery. I also bought some Cardano as I thought the idea was cool, although it may very well come to nothing.

  • yeah bought some back in Sept at around $0.70 ish too.
    I'm just affraid it's a pump and dump…
    But I don't have too much to lose.
    Wait and see

  • +1

    You took 1 snapshot at a volatile time.
    Australian market has no liquidity, so all exchanges and exchange services spot price can trade at a discount or a premium pretty easily if there is enough buy or sell pressure.
    You need more data to conclude that coinbase is cheaper.

    • +2

      Fair point. Will watch this for a while. I guess all I'm saying is don't take statements like "coinbase is more expensive" at face value. It's like a shop putting a "crazy bargain" sign on something, doesn't necessarily make it so…. :-)

  • -1

    coinspot is in Australian dollar and coinbase is in US

    • Partially correct. Coinbase is US, but now supports Australia directly. If you create an account it will use AUD. All comparisons above are in AUD. I would note that you can only buy coins via Coinbase, you can't sell (you need to move coins to a different exchange).

Login or Join to leave a comment