Online Buys Prompt Retail Inquiry

The growing trend to shop online has prompted a government inquiry into Australia's retail sector amid complaints by traditional retailers that shoppers are avoiding paying GST by buying goods from overseas websites.
The federal government on Saturday announced a Productivity Commission inquiry into the future of the sector and a crackdown on businesses rorting the system to avoid paying tax.
Traditional retailers want the government to scrap the $1000 GST-free threshold for imported goods, arguing it puts them at an unfair disadvantage in competing with online stores.
Assistant Treasurer Bill Shorten said consumers should be able to shop in whatever manner they choose, including online.
"The case for lowering the threshold has significant opposition, including the cost of collection and consumer objections," Mr Shorten said in a statement.
""However, we are taking the concerns of retailers seriously, which is why I have asked the Productivity Commission to look into these issues."
Thanks to the strong Australian dollar, consumers are increasingly turning to overseas websites for GST-free purchases.
A raft of retailers have complained they are losing out to foreign websites and are campaigning against the threshold while the likes of Myer and Harvey Norman have flagged setting up websites to ship goods directly from China to Australian consumers.
Home Affairs Minister Brendan O'Connor said the government would conduct a compliance campaign to ensure GST and customs duty concession for imports worth $1000 or less were not being abused or exploited.
"It's important people follow the rules and not try to rort the system," he said.
The crackdown will begin in 2011.
The moves came as Access Economics figures showed Australians spent $19-24 billion buying goods online in 2009, representing about three per cent of total sales.
The report showed at least 50 per cent and up to 80 per cent of that amount was spent with Australian onlineretail outlets.
Communications Minister Stephen Conroy said with online retailing only accounting for three per cent of the Australian total, there was great potential for it to grow.
Australia's retail turnover was $242 billion for the 12 months to October.

http://au.news.yahoo.com/latest/a/-/latest/8532830/online-bu…

discuss….

Comments

  • It Was Gerry Harvey complaining about this because his bussiness is suffering?He closed down his stores in ireland etc,Competition is good but not in the eyes of Harvey norman,drop your prices to an acceptable level instead of having a 1000%markup on most goods,or shut up!!

  • +3

    I love it how people whinge about this sort of stuff out of context. (looks at harvey)

    Big things like tvs still attract GST, plus postage is wayyy more expensive than his container loads of importing goods.

    The reason why tax isnt charged on items less than a grand is because the GST is $100, and its not financially viable to collect it.

    Electronics in sydney have been really overpriced until msy came in and pulled the prices down.

    The markups on so many products in australia are so high, even if i imported them AND paid GST they would still be significantly cheaper.

  • +1

    I'll bet that most of the online sales of products which Myer and Harvey's stock, are actually bought from Australian websites and posted within Australia, with GST included in the price. Seriously, does anyone buy a tv directly from China and pay for the shipping? The postage costs enough within Australia.

    If 3% of retail sales are online, how much of that is from overseas? Half of it or less? That's what, like, 1.5%? And of that 1.5% you could only count 10% of that for GST… so I guess we're talking about 0.15% lol!

    GST is hardly an issue here. The old traditional bricks and mortar stores who whinge about it should get with the times. In any case, I'll bet that Harvey's and co have lost most of their business to up and coming stores like JB HiFi. Kogan is probably another example, and again, they do collect GST. The world is getting smaller and the internet is presenting new oportunities. Big deal. We shouldn't be trying to protect Myer's extortionate markups, nor these big companies share prices.

    • +1

      totally agree

      The old traditional bricks and mortar stores who whinge about it should get with the times

      Quoted for truth. +++rep

      There are two types of stores at the moment.

      • Warehouse, no consumer access
      • Shop front - consumer based.

      Harvey is having a cry because not EVERYONE needs to go out and look at the store before buying. When i go looking for a tv, i know exactly what i want - i dont need to look at a screen to see if its good, basically they're all the same standard (if the specs are the same)

      • find smaller stores with room for display models only
      • have "pick up points" where users can buy the tv either online, or at a display room, then pick it up the next day from one of these small places.
      • have a centralised warehouse for all major cities that does dropoffs to the drop off points.

      Harvey should get his act together, find out what people want, and cater for those needs. Its not the first industry thats fallen behind, then had a cry because they're making no more money.

      /me gets off the soapbox.

  • I don't know why amazon haven't jumped in here and made a killing……..
    too small a market I suppose….

    • US shipping kills it basically. Still, there are many products that EVEN WITH usps shipping, its still half price of what it is here.

      I also think alot of companies have agreements with their distributor of where they can ship stuff. (half the problem tbh)

      Perfect example.

      This rock hammer

      In australia - $100
      ANY US hardware store - $30, national delivery.

Login or Join to leave a comment