Forced to Pay for eBay Plus

Hey Guys,

Disclaimer: This experience has made me doubt myself, but I 100% remember cancelling my eBay Plus Trial, before the questions of "are you sure you cancelled"

Now to begin:

Had subscribed to eBay Plus Trial.
Was most recently on 90 Day Trial with setting of it being cancelled and can recall that on the "eBay Plus" page it was showing as subscription will end on blah blah blah date.

I get a notification today from PayPal that I have paid $49 to eBay, I go to check and my Plus has been renewed. Below is the chat with support.

eBay Plus subscription auto-renewed when it was set not to…
2019 - 02 - 09
08:58:06 UTC Alfie
Welcome to eBay Plus Premium Service!
08:58:19 UTC yousifoheight
Hi Alfie
08:58:28 UTC Alfie
Hello Yousif.
08:58:35 UTC yousifoheight
I believe I had set my preference for eBay Plus to not auto renew
08:58:45 UTC yousifoheight
I've just got a PayPal notification saying it has
08:59:51 UTC Alfie
I see. Allow me to check your subscription details here.
09:01:21 UTC Alfie
I checked your subscription details and can confirm that your 90-days free trial ended just today. I can also confirm that you have been moved to paid subscription.
09:01:42 UTC Alfie
So, you're saying that you cancelled within the 90-days free trial. Is that correct?
09:01:49 UTC yousifoheight
09:02:56 UTC Alfie
Apparently, there are no records of it here in our end.
09:03:03 UTC Alfie
Also, we noticed that this has already been your 3rd free trial of eBay Plus.
09:03:29 UTC yousifoheight
I am quite sure I set it as cancelled after the trial period
09:03:46 UTC yousifoheight
eBay sends me these offers and I accept them?
09:05:08 UTC Alfie
Well, these offers are pretty much automated and are sent to everyone.
09:05:12 UTC Alfie
It's also on the terms and conditions that you can only take advantage of the free trial once.
09:05:14 UTC Alfie
Normally, if you decide to subscribe to eBay Plus again after subscribing to a free trial before, you'll be charged right away for the annual fee.
09:05:54 UTC yousifoheight
So you're saying I should pay because I've received more than 1 trial, that eBay themselves has offered to me…
09:05:59 UTC yousifoheight
Don't send them to everyone then.
09:07:05 UTC Alfie
Technically speaking, you should be on paid membership now after taking advantage of a couple of free trials already.
09:07:21 UTC yousifoheight
Not to mention the fact I am also very well aware of the fact that eBay is now targeting users with 180 day free trials
09:07:27 UTC yousifoheight
Seems to me the service is not so "great"
09:08:00 UTC yousifoheight
You can't tell me I should already be paying after your system has offered me multiple trials.
09:08:07 UTC yousifoheight
A trial is just that. A TRIAL
09:08:16 UTC yousifoheight
There is no forced subscription that must follow
09:11:26 UTC Alfie
Once again, please know that you can only take advantage of the free trial once, as per terms and conditions. I'm not saying that we're forcing you to subscribe or move to paid membership.
09:11:27 UTC Alfie
I hope you understand that it's also your responsibility to make sure that you follow the conditions that we have and make sure that your membership is cancelled before moving to paid membership.
09:11:40 UTC Alfie
Anyway, I presume that you'd like to get a refund for the annual fee that was charged.
09:11:59 UTC yousifoheight
As I mentioned I am 100% in the belief that I did cancel it
09:12:23 UTC yousifoheight
I have visited my eBay plus page multiple times during the subscription and have noted the message of "Your subscription will end on *****"
09:12:41 UTC yousifoheight
I would like to opt out of eBay plus and this time and receive a refund
09:14:52 UTC Alfie
If it was cancelled, then the subscription shouldn't have moved to paid membership.
09:14:53 UTC Alfie
About getting a refund, please know that the annual fee is non-refundable as per terms and conditions.
09:15:11 UTC yousifoheight
09:15:15 UTC yousifoheight
Of course it isn't
09:15:27 UTC yousifoheight
Wouldn't want people getting a refund for a shit paid subscription would ya?
09:16:33 UTC Alfie
I'm sorry. I hope you understand that I'm only following the terms and conditions that we have.
09:16:54 UTC yousifoheight
That's okay, I'll get my reversal through PayPal
09:17:20 UTC yousifoheight
This makes eBay look very bad…
09:17:52 UTC Alfie
We'll respect whatever actions you will take.
09:18:09 UTC yousifoheight
Thank you.
09:18:13 UTC
Chat ended by yousifoheight

Related Stores

eBay Australia
eBay Australia


  • +14 votes

    Pretty sure the business model of eBay Plus is to make money from forgetful people who don't cancel their trial.

    • +2 votes

      Yes, that's well and true.

      What I'm trying to discover is if anyone else like me believes they had cancelled their subscription and also got forced into an auto-renew.


      Same as Free rental video ezy. You forget to return, you pay 100% overnight price. That's why they can always give you free rental.

  • +6 votes

    Lesson learn that you did not cancel the pay agreement from paypal for ebay

  • +2 votes

    I have had the same issue with ebay. The douchebag on the other end said we can't refund you because of T&C. I told them to go screw themselves. Removed all my cards and money from bank account. I might get a dishonour fee but hopefully once I dispute the dumb transaction I will get it back.

    However, I am having trouble disputing the transaction on paypal. Screen just doesn't load once I click dispute.

    • +2 votes

      Yep, I submitted my case as fraudulent transaction, ironic how you can't successfully dispute this particular payment on PayPal cause the page keeps freezing hey?

  • +12 votes


    OP has been using eBay Plus trial. May have forgot (which later was upgraded to 100% belief) to cancel auto renew to paid user. Wants a refund.

    CS explains that there is no record of cancellation.

    Insert a lot of repetition by OP about trial periods and other irrelevant information

    CS informs OP that the annual membership is non-refundable once paid.

    CS responded amicably throughout. OP… not so much.

    • +1 vote

      Yeah OP doesn't come out as the more reasonable person here. Especially - why can't I get multiple free trials just vendor eBay emails them to me, never mind they say first time only?


    This happened to me a while ago during the google home mini promotion. They said they couldn't refund me because the home mini was already sent. I insisted that I'll return the home mini; and they gave me back my refund.

  • +5 votes

    eBay wouldn't even give me a refund when I canceled ~9 months of my paid membership remaining due to my ebay account bugging out. I couldn't even use it if I wanted to nor transfer it to a working account.

    Did you get a private PM from eBay regarding your trial cancellation/s? Would be handy to show paypal re your claim.

    They are something like

    eBay inbox
    You've ended your eBay Plus membership, penguincat
    Sent:06-Feb-19 08:42

    Your eBay Plus membership will end on 24/02/2019.

    Sorry blah blah

    Email reference ID: numbers and letters.

    If you don't have that then 1. You didn't cancel it 2. It bugged out and didn't cancel correctly. 3.You deleted it when you really shouldn't have. :p

  • +2 votes

    Top kek right there… Terms and conditions say that you sould not have more than one free trial, but they offer it for free and it's up to me to police their accounting policy and rewards? Dumb arses.

    Thanks for the warning though, went and screen shot my eBay Plus membership page as evidence.

  • +1 vote

    Happened to me too after my second trial. Although I was nowhere near as polite as you no refund. PayPal escalation then refund. Also well done on being so polite wish I had that control when I'm mad.

  • +5 votes

    Did you recieve an email saying your + was cancelled?

  • +2 votes

    I don’t think you cancelled your membership

  • +10 votes

    If you play the game, know the rules.

    09:03:03 UTC Alfie
    Also, we noticed that this has already been your 3rd free trial of eBay Plus.

  • +1 vote

    I have been charged $146.97 for 3 accounts.

    It is my firm opinion I cancelled these trials on the eBay site. Not with Paypal.

    In following the Paypal Resolution Centre procedure, I'm not able to proceed past the 'Continue to Report' tab, as the next screen doesn't open.

    Anyone else having this problem?

    eBay Plus proved of little or no value to me.


    I got this today too. I too was sure I cancelled on eBay's site (and said it would end on X date), but it was still down as a payment in PayPal.

    I've emailed eBay about this, since I can't put this through PayPal either. Freezes on the page after hitting "Continue to Report".


      Spoke to them on the phone. Since cancellation wasn't effective, they say it never happened. (Dealing with their support was Kafkaesque, though the supervisor confirmed that they thought I was just lying)

      I tried to cancel again last night and didn't get a confirmation email, but did this morning when I tried again. Same browser etc too.

      eBay are unwilling to consider that there might be something wrong with their form. Not sure what the next steps are, since going through PayPal doesn't work either.


    This happened to me. Ebay is currently investigating if they can give me a refund because I made 0 ebay plus purchases during my trial, and I contacted them as soon as I got the paypal notification.

    Edit: They've informed me I'll have an answer by Friday 15/02/2019


      Ebay has agreed to refund the amount, but suggest it's going to take a while.

      Hello my name,

      This is about your refund request for the annual fee for your eBay Plus membership.

      I already reviewed your account and I am happy to inform you that I will be helping you get refunded for the annual fee that was charged for your eBay Plus Membership.

      This will take about 2 to 4 weeks or 30 days since the charge just reflected in your account and for us to credit the subscription fee, we have to wait for it to clear in your account.

      I will personally look into this to help you with your refund request, all you need to do is just wait patiently and I will send you an update.

      I trust that this information will help resolve your concern.

      Thanks for choosing eBay. Have a great day!



    I had the same thing happen to me today thinking I had also cancelled. Emailing eBay was the same response as OP, and also same issue with paypal attempting to dispute the transaction. I eventually managed to dispute it through paypal as unauthorised access.


      It worked! "Unfortunately, the payment for your eBay Plus subscription was declined. Please contact your bank for more information regarding the cause of the decline.

      As we didn’t receive the payment, we have cancelled your eBay Plus membership. If you want to continue to be a member of eBay Plus, you can sign up again."


    Lodged a dispute with paypal first, which was declined. Then I decided to have a go with eBay via chat, and managed to get a refund.


    Thank you everyone.
    Paypal asked me to contact bank.
    I am going to fill out disputed transaction form tmr.
    I will tell you the result.


    I got charged the $48.99 too by ebay through Paypal. Has anyone successfully claimed there money back?

  • Top