Some Direction and Advice Needed - Qnap NAS Not Booting

Hello All….

I have a QNAP TS-419P+…YES…I know its an old one, but it was serving my purpose really well, so I was fine with it. It was configured with 4x 2TB HDDs as RAID5.

I walked in today…and without warning the unit was going into a perpetual boot cycle…attempting to boot. It would…whir up…fail..try again..whir up…fail..try again…and so on. I had to pull the power to power it down.

I immediately suspected the power supply brick as I could hear it whining and buzzing…but I just am not sure. Here is what I tried…

  • Took out all the HDDs and put them away…
  • Powered the unit on with no HDDs
    ** QNAPs Qfinder Pro tool on my PC was able to find the unit, but complained and wouldnt log me on as there were no HDDs

  • Next I tried a spare 2.5" HDD in each NAS Slot
    ** Slot 1 and 2…went back to boot cycling as described
    ** Slot 3….this did allow me to boot the unit….Just!!
    ** Slot 4…went further with the boot process, but eventually cycled back…

  • Next I tried a spare 3.5" HDD in each NAS Slot
    ** Slot 1 and 2…went back to boot cycling as described
    ** Slot 3 and 4…went further with the boot process, but eventually cycled back…

When the unit did boot with the 2.5" HDD QFinder Pro found the unit and it seemed to be showing the right firmware…(QTS 4.3.3.2784). This can also be seen on the front panel…yet when I tried to login, its telling me to install firmware. I have no idea why this would be the case!! Happy to hear some ideas!!

Throughout this testing, the power brick was whining and buzzing…and the noise would change…and the power brick LED would dim when the unit power cycled.
Of note…the power supply brick is whining/buzzing a lot which I dont belive it had been doing.

I strongly suspect there is a power issue here…but I wanted to see if this community could offer some thoughts or advice. Not really sure where to turn after this!

Thank you All…

Stulte.

Comments

  • Time to buy a new one :/

    That's where cheap PCs as NAS have the edge (I run a couple cheap AMD5600Gs), when they break it is much easier to troubleshoot and replace parts!

    Wait until you try to get the data back off an old RAID5 array that is manufacturer specific (the drives are not readable by other NASes) …

    • The second statement applies to almost all raid controllers / nas…

  • Lucky for you the TS-419P+ doesn't use proprietary raid controllers so the data can be retrieved.

    Have you tested the power supply? It's an external brick so getting a replacement should be quite easy.

    • Yes. I have ordered a new power brick. Need to see how that pans out once it arrives.

  • Id look at reinstalling the firmware or Recovering the Firmware

    https://www.qnap.com/en/how-to/faq/article/nas-recovery-guid…

Login or Join to leave a comment