Does 5 Year Old Flagship Phone = Modern Budget Phone

I have often wondered if the current budget mobile smartphones (in my use case, the Samsung Galaxy's) with the lesser-known model names such as the 'A05s' are just restamped flagship (or plus) phones from the past.

I can say from a recent experience, that they definitely are not.

The A05s that I took for a test drive (while good value for under $200), was definitely not up to scratch of a Galaxy+ from 2019. (even though the A05s was released in 2023, it is a current budget phone available though most outlets).

In comparison it was laggy, picture quality took a dive, sometimes does not respond when taking a photo, constant flash light when shooting video, poorer mobile reception (no bars vs 2 bars on old plus). Basically a whole lot of things that I just haven't really seen mentioned in the comparison sites.

Just mentioning this out of interest. It is good in a way for those spending $1200+ on a new phone, as it at least helps to justify the cost. Waiting 5 years to get todays tech at a budget price may apply in principle (to varying degrees), but there is a noticeable difference in build quality, speed & functionality.

I think the best outcome for those not wanting to spend top dollar is to purchase a second hand plus or ultra, rather than a new budget.

Like a second hand car, you don't know how reliable it will be, but if there are no problems the everyday user experience will be a lot better.

Has anyone had any bad experiences purchasing second hand 'reconditioned' or 'refurbished' phones from commercial online retailers?

Comments

  • +5

    The A05s that I took for a test drive (while good value for under $200), was definitely not up to scratch of a Galaxy+ from 2019.

    Samsung still needs to make a profit selling the phone.

    For a phone that retails $200~$250, if we assume that Samsung has profit margin of say, $100 per unit, they'll have to cheap out by using a processor that's already several generations old and use bottom of the barrel LCD displays, camera modules, speakers etc..

    You can't compare it to a flagship phone built 5 years ago and had an original retail price of $1200+. Those margins would have allowed Samsung to put in whatever was the best SoC, display and camera modules at the time. If you factor in inflation, that $1200 device back then might actually be $1500 in today's money.

    Does 5 Year Old Flagship Phone = Modern Budget Phone? The answer is depends, we've seen some absolutely crazy prices for modern budget phones that have specs that are on equal footing with older flagship Galaxy S series.

  • Replaced the battery in my Galaxy S20FE recently (released Oct 2020). It works fine for my basic use & takes awesome pics & video.

    Don't see any reason to upgrade.

  • +2

    I am still very happy with my S10. It performs better and I prefer it to the new budget phones I have tried (and best of all it has a headphone jack)

    The only thing is that the battery has degraded, but I would rather replace it than switch to a new budget phone

  • +1

    There are good value budget phones and there are poor value budget phones.

    Before the whole network blacklist debacle, POCOs and the like were leaps and bounds better value than their Samsung budget counterparts. My old POCO X3 Pro does some stuff better than my current S21+.

  • +1

    I noticed that the display on the Motorola G84 was poorer than the Samsung Note 8 which I had used a long time ago. The processor speeds probably similar.I am not sure about camera.

    All in all,I think better to buy a flagship phone and keep it for a long time rather than buy new budget phones every couple of years.

    • Best to buy MId range every 5 years IMHO. I like the pixel Xa series despite their battery swell issues.

  • There's a reason people spend so much money on flagship phones and update them every few years.

    • What's that?

      • So the phones don't feel slow as balls. Even a split second delay when doing things can grate.

  • I never buy budget or midrange phones anymore. I exclusively buy high end flagships. I also prefer larger screen sizes so that limits my options to:

    • Google
      • Pixel 10 Pro XL
      • Pixel 9 Pro XL
      • Pixel 8 Pro
      • Pixel 7 Pro
      • Pixel 6 Pro
    • Apple
      • iPhone 17 Pro Max
      • iPhone 16 Pro Max
      • iPhone 15 Pro Max
      • iPhone 14 Pro Max
      • iPhone 13 Pro Max
    • Samsung
      • Galaxy S25 Ultra
      • Galaxy S24 Ultra
      • Galaxy S23 Ultra
      • Galaxy S22 Ultra
      • Galaxy S21 Ultra

    This way know I know I have one of best phones of a particular year. Budget and midrange phones have compromises. Yes, a newer FE or A series is likely better than the S21 Ultra but the S21 wasn't built with compromises. The build quality matters to me, even if it's placebo. Specs don't matter to me beyond being flagship hence why I like Pixel over iPhone and Galaxy because even though it's weaker, I like its software and design more, and it usually has better deals. I currently have the Pixel 8 Pro. If a good deal for Pixel 9/10 Pro XL comes, I'll likely trade it in for that.

Login or Join to leave a comment