Are $1 Servo Coffees as Good as $4 Cafe Coffees?

Long time coffee drinker, first time coffee question writer.

While I love a latte or flat white from a nice little coffee shop and the ambience, of I’m on the go I find it hard to not save 75% and get one from Coles Express, 7/11, etc

Do you guys reckon you could tell the difference in a blind test? To be honest, I don’t think I could. Even if you could slightly tell, is 400% price increase enough to buy the $1 Latte?

As noted by a commenter, most things cost more when it comes to food and perception of quality, but I think the difference here is the 400% markup for coffee shop coffee. Over a year that’s a lot. $1 x 365 = $365. $4 x 365 = $1,460.

Poll Options

  • 271
    $1 Coffees do the job
  • 127
    I only go for the expensive stuff
  • 106
    Coffee tastes like dirt

Comments

  • +11 votes

    The more milk, the less the difference IMO.

    I like a small latte and prefer barista coffee. But it's a rip at $4-5. Happy with a $1 servo when an urgent caffeine hit is required.

  • +39 votes

    Answer is no, $1 coffees are not as good as coffees made on an espresso machine by a skilled barista, but if I need coffee and I am stopped at a service station that sells them I am quite happy to have one

  • +33 votes

    There's a major difference in flavour but if you're asking this question then you probably won't be able to tell.

    • +1 vote

      Between one particular coffee shop and servo lattes or all $4 coffee shops? I would argue that some coffee shops serve coffee that’s not as good as servo coffee. I know of one locally. Maybe it’s subjective

      • +21 votes

        They'd have to be an absolutely terrible coffee shop to sell anything worse than servo coffee.

        • +2 votes

          Did you mention Coffee Club?

          At least the servo $1 coffee was hotter than the junk that i've been fortunate to drink from the Coffee Club.

        • +6 votes

          Not really. Servo coffees are made by automated machine, thus quality is relatively consistently irrespective of how bad you think they are.

          Coffee shop ones however, there's the bean, how it's extracted, barista's skill, milk frothing, etc etc variables that can all fk things up. I'm used to getting rubbish coffee club and star bucks coffee

          •  

            @berry580: 7/11 machine is rather expensive and has a high turnover of beans so are quite fresh, it’s quite good and constent

          • +1 vote

            @berry580: I would honestly be doubtful that the servo coffee machine gets cleaned regularly enough.

            I've seen enough of those milk tubes after a few days of use to never touch an automated milk pump coffee again.

      • +4 votes

        A quality cafe will use different beans to what a servo would use. The beans will cost a lot more as well and have a different taste.

        People who are used to drinking finer beans should be able to tell the difference to a servo coffee. $1 coffee drinkers (just to get a hit) are like those people who can’t tell the difference between a $500 bottle of grange and a $10 merlot.

        You’d also need to factor in the barista and how the coffee is extracted but like for like it should be a no brainer.

    • -3 votes

      May I interject, out of all the coffee shops I went to including the Lindt cafe. Even though Lindt has very good coffee, it I prefer mcdonald’s Mocha if made correctly that is hot with extra chocolate powder(otherwise too bitter for me I prefer sweet coffee)k

    •  

      I know the difference and i often pay $4 for a terrible coffee near my work.

      Lazyness trumps all I guess

  • +6 votes

    It depends how clean the servo machine is, I prefer the foodary at Woolworths or 7/11
    And depends on the barista at cafe I’ve had really bad $5 coffees and really good ones.
    I drink both cafe and servo but so many variables, hard to give a fair comparison.

  • +8 votes

    Bought my own rancilio set up so always make my own now. Compared to my home coffee, 7-11 tastes like dirt.

    •  

      What rancilio do you own and how does it compare to something like the breville bes920?

      • +6 votes

        I'm gonna guess they have the Sylvia, the main difference is one is dual boiler and the other is not meaning you could extract coffee and steam milk at the same time.

        Another consideration is that the Sylvia is well documented and parts readily available, they should last a long time but if it breaks, easy to get parts and repair yourself if need be.

        If a Breville dies you may not have the same success finding parts.

        Check out the coffeesnobs forum, someone will have compared the two machines I'm sure.

        • +3 votes

          Nailed it :) Also, it's just a workhorse, i have had it over 4 years with no problems with it, i have replaced some washers on the steam tap, that's about it.

          I also had a PID put on mine which helped a lot more with temp control.

          I'd love to upgrade to a Linea Mini or something along those lines but don't think the Mrs will let me spend that amount haha.

          • +2 votes

            @crashloaded: Silvia owner here too. Our machine was shorting out for some reason so I ended up buying a new water pump and replacing it thinking that was the cause. However, I think it was just a loose earth somewhere as some screws were a little loose. Anyway, point being is that I’m not usually handy with appliances but the Silvia is quite easy to dismantle and put back together.

          • +4 votes

            @crashloaded: Another Silvia owner here. Ours is about 10 years old and still going strong. Never had it professionally serviced as nothing has gone wrong with it so far. I just undertake regular descaling and replacement of rubber washer above the grouphead. The Mrs won't let me upgrade either. I secretly want it to break down so I can upgrade, but this thing seems to be built like a tank!

            Happy barrista-ing everyone.

          •  

            @crashloaded: How much did it cost to install PID?

  • +5 votes

    I usually get long black/ice long black. To me the 7-11/caltex ones are as good as any other barrista made ones. The coles ones were by far the worst Ive ever had though. Like ground up chicken bones in a brown broth and children's tears.

  • +2 votes

    The options are not what the questions asking…

    $1 Coffees certainly do the job, but I could certainly taste the difference between a local cafe coffee and a Coles Express Coffee.

    Between a random cafe, a machine made (ie ALDI or Nespresso) and a Coles Express Coffee would be interesting though. Depends on the cafe.

    • -1 vote

      True. Would like to see a blind test. Results would be similar to the wine aficionados I think

    •  

      We have a Nespresso and my sister has the Aldi one. The Nespresso is far better but, of course, everything is far more expensive too.

  • +3 votes

    The beans/blend and the barista can make coffee taste different, even between coffee shops.
    Taste is personal, so if you like 7/11 coffee then just buy it from there. If you worry about workplace perception, use a reusable cup and it could have came from anywhere.

    • +1 vote

      I could not possibly care less about what my colleagues think about the cost of my coffee 😂

  •  

    if saving $3 makes a difference then definitely same thing. I drink coffee only for caffeine and happy with coles express $80 cents deal.

    • +2 votes

      I drink coffee only for caffeine

      Why not just buy this? 8c a hit, surely a much cheaper delivery mechanism than the cheapest coffee.

      • +3 votes

        Funny that the 200 pill bottle costs more than twice the 100 pill bottle. Maybe everyone is too hepped up on caffeine to notice.

  • +22 votes

    I like my coffee just like I like my women.

    Cheap and from a service station.

  • +1 vote

    They are certainly not on par. I would easily know which is the 7-11 and which is a cafe coffee. In fact I would be able to tell the difference between a 7-11 and coles express. Having said that, the $1 coffees do the job and I would choose them unless I felt like treating myself.

    •  

      I’m on the same boat here. On the go; who cares. A bit of self care; at a coffee shop and soak it up

  • +6 votes

    In my experience servo coffees are or close to instant coffee and that's disgusting. Barista all the way.

  • +1 vote

    If I just want a pick-me-up, $1 coffee is fine. But to sit down with a friend or read a paper, which isn't something you can do at 7 Eleven, I'd get a $5 coffee,

    •  

      Yep, I think this is about me too

    •  

      You can sit down with friends opposite the Eddy Ave 7- Eleven at Central Station and have a chat with the friendly hobos, and still have $4 to spare.

  • +1 vote

    lol depends where you go

  • -3 votes

    Taste is largely determined by pre concieved notions.

    So coffee drinkers will taste "barista" coffee or "pod coffee" and taste differences even though they are drinking the same thing for example.

    Wine drinkers taste red wine when drinking white wine with red food colouring if they are none the wiser.

  • +4 votes

    I've been an auditor for 7-Eleven and I can tell you that all franchisees are not created equal - with some of them not changing the milk as often as they should.

    • +1 vote

      Wow, gross! Let’s hope their popularity keeps the milk fresh 😳

      • -1 vote

        The term you're looking for is high turnover. And milk going off due to low turnover is horrifying to think about…

    • +1 vote

      How often were stores audited and was there a sign of a recent audit, ie certificate or customers won't know?

  • Top