Stainless Steel Frypan

Hi all, so I've finally been scared enough from the barrage of media saying non stick/teflon are bad for you and am now willing to spend 3x the time cleaning a stainless steel pan. (Yes i know if i use oil, wait for it to be hot enough, test with a drop of water yada yada)

Looking for a frypan around 24-28cm. Looking to spend under $100 on it, I saw the tefal virtuoso and scanpan on amazon. Wondering if these are the go or if there are any better options.

EDIT: Forgot to mention needs to be induction compatible.

Thanks

Comments

Search through all the comments in this post.
  • +8

    Have you looked at carbon steel? Like de Buyer, among others

    • I've tried that, but cannot find a use case where teflon or stainless steel does not do a better job. Or even enamelled steel.
      The non-stick patina performs poorly compared to teflon, and for high-temp steak searing, stainless does the job equally well but is easy to clean, and low maintenance.

    • Love the Debuyer carbon steel crepe pan we have for a few years now.

  • +8

    I know you said stainless steel - but IMO you need a cast iron pan and a stainless steel pan (different uses).

    • +1

      What would you use a stainless steel pan for that you wouldn't want a cast iron for? I've just started using cast iron and use it for everything.

      • Cast iron needs reseasoning, and retains a lot of heat, and is heavy as (profanity). Also cleaning is a bit of a pain in the balls.

        We reserve our cast iron for steaks and flatbreads and the like.

        Everything else gets cooked on the stainless steel all-clad pots and pans.

        • The cast iron crepe pans work well for a steak for 1 or 2, and it’s light

          • +1

            @Vomo: Yeah we have one of those, but since my technique for getting really amazing steak involves spooning pooled butter and herbs back onto the steak to make it extra juicy, only a deep cast iron pan works.

            We use teh crepe pan for flatbreads, tacos and the like.

            • @ThadtheChad: Sounds like an awesome way to cook a steak!

              • @Vomo: I like doing this instead of the reverse sear method for thinner cuts (reverse sear would overcook them).

                It's really good! This is a bit naughty as its not the healthiest thing in the world, but you can spoon the crispy garlic and burn bits onto some Japanese rice with some furikake, a teaspoon of japanese soup base and a raw egg.

                We love slicing up the steak in thin slices and piling it on top of the rice, and then adding a dollop of wasabi on top.

        • I use exclusively cast iron, and have no idea why people have trouble cleaning them, or why they see the need to reseason them.

          You might get a spot of rust on them from time to time. So what? Just wash it off.

          • @cannedhams: When you have all manner of cookware, pick whatever is personal preference/best kit for the job. If you haven't tried good stainless steel yet, you definitely should give it a go IMHO. I say this as someone who was an ardent "cast-iron" fan for years.

            Just a small point of clarification, I meant re-seasoning "touch-ups", not full on re-seasoning. Although I'm a bit OCD, my cast iron skillet has a mirror finish on the seasoning. There would be no chance, my cast iron or carbon steel kit would have rust on it.

            We are definitely quite familiar with cast iron cookware and have a lot of cast iron equipment (a few Le creuset dutch ovens and casseroles, a giant Staub, flat griddles,a crepe pan, and my big 5kg 15" Lodge skillet).

            At present, however, our preference is using our stainless steel/copper pans for general cooking (especially if it involves acidic materials like sauces and the like) and then cast iron for any large meat cooking (steaks, chops etc). Carbon steel wok/skillet for Asian high heat cooking.

    • I don't think you need cast iron at all.

      I prefer to use it for steaks, but many pros swear by stainless

  • +5

    Interesting thread. Here is the data in summary if you scrolled through it.

    Brand Name Type Sentiment Score Count of Reviewers Price (AUD) Value Index
    IKEA Sensuell Tri-ply Stainless Steel +5 4 $69 0.0725
    IKEA 365+ Stainless Steel +3 2 $29 0.1034
    Tefal Virtuoso Stainless Steel + Non-Stick -2 1 $114.99 -0.0174
    Scanpan Impact Stainless Steel -2 1 $84.95 -0.0235
    All-Clad D5 Tri-ply Stainless Steel +2 1 $499 0.0040
    Baccarat Gourmet Stainless Steel 0 1 $99.99 0.0000
    Essteele Per Sempre Tri-ply Stainless Steel +1 1 $194.95 0.0051
    • +1

      $500 All-Clad?? Is it handle golden?

    • I have Essteele Per Sempre cookware. While it's very well made, tbh it is unnecessarily heavy and quite utilitarian aesthetically. It really will last for ever. I bought it because it was advertised as the 'most premium' collection but I wish I had bought the Per Vita which is a little more elegant.

  • +4

    EDIT: Forgot to mention needs to be induction compatible.

    All stainless steel will be induction compatible.

    Not all stainless steel is the same. I have a scanpan frypan and also a wok style one from Team Skottsberg which was a lot more, but I tend to use it for 90% of my cooking.

    Don't give up with stainless when you get it. 99% of the time when people get frustrated with it, it's their cooking method. There's several key things to be aware of when cooking on stainless such as heating it up properly and doing the "water bead" test before putting oil on, letting food naturally separate etc.

    Get yourself a stainless steel cleaner too for when there's baked on stuff, don't use metal utensils, don't use a steel pad to clean it and don't shock it with cold water after using it.

    Love it and it will last for decades.

    • I found some of our very old stainless steel pans don't work on induction. Must be the base layer.
      Now i do the magnet test.
      If it sticks strongly to base of pan, it works well on induction.
      If it sticks weakly or doesn't stick, then don't use it on induction.

      • that because they use different material for the base probably Aluminium or use cheaper stainless steel in the 300 series which doesn't contain good amount of ferromagnetic

    • doing the "water bead" test before putting oil on

      What oil do you use?
      I'm trying to avoid the veg ones but the good olive oils aren't compatible with the bead test temperatures.

      Beef tallow is awesome for steaks but expensive and not great for less meaty dishes.

      • +1

        Coconut oil, avocado oil, hi oleic peanut oil, macadamia oil

    • Definitely not true. To work with induction the metal has to be ferromagnetic. Most common grades of SS are not ferro magnetic. You need to make sure they are listed as induction compatible or they will not heat at all.

      I have many very high end stainless pots from well before induction cooktops were a thing, and none of them are magnetic, and they don't work on induction.

      • well that's something new. makes sense and why i see pans with "copper bases" I guess.

        • Copper base is a layer of copper as part of a metallic sandwich base to help with even heat over the base. Copper is a great heat conductor, stainless is not.

  • +3

    You'll have this pan for life, up your budget a little, set up an alert and grab an 12-inch All-Clad D3 fry pan when it drops to $200 on Amazon. Top of the line when it comes to stainless clad pans.

    • +2
    • +1

      We initially got an All-Clad D5 pan. Loved it so much after a few years we got the whole set of pots and pans.

      Few years hence, they're pretty much the mainstay of our kitchen and we cook A LOT!!

    • I have All-Clad cookware.

      Some of their cookware can't be put in the dishwasher. They were sued over this and settled in the USA.
      https://www.americastestkitchen.com/articles/6466-what-the-a…

      I have impacted cookware from All-Clad, but not being from USA I get nothing. I would recommend staying away from this brand.

      • +3

        This is universal for stainless clad pans due to the exposed aluminium layer at the edge of the pan. So you can get a worse performing pan without an aluminium layer (worse heat distribution) or just get stainless clad and wash by hand.

        All-Clad topped SeriousEats reviews for years until MadeIn came along and the equivalent MadeIn pan is about twice the price. MadeIn also advises not to put in dishwasher.

        • +1

          Yeah I didn't realize this at the time. The pans used to say dishwasher safe, but they never were. They should be responsible for replacing all impacted cookware IMO.

          My D3 pot has a noticeable lip after being in the dishwasher like 2-3 times.

          • @Aureus: Yeah that is shitty of them to advertise being dishwasher safe but as long as you know not to put in the dishwasher All-Clad is the go.

      • Why would a dishwasher damage a stainless steel pan?

        • +4

          Because the middle aluminum layer is exposed on the edge. That layer gets damaged by the dish-washing powder, but the stainless steel layer above and below is not impacted. As a result you get a sharp lip around the edge.

          Other multi-layered cookware have the same issue, but All-Clad advertised that their pans were dishwasher-safe, when they never were.

  • +2

    Check out a commercial kitchen/caterers supply mob, if you want good, reasonably priced ss pans

    • Yep, I get Forje stainless stuff as a staple. They are great quality and a 280mm frying pan is $65inc. A conical saucepan or saucier is a really useful pan to have too. Being commercial pans means they are cheap, effective and bulletproof (probably literally and metaphorically).

  • +2

    Scanpan is nice

    solidteknic noni is nice but $$$

  • +2

    I've had success with Ikea's stainless steel frying pan

    both the 24 and 28cm is the same price $69

    https://www.ikea.com/au/en/p/sensuell-frying-pan-stainless-s…

    I paid closer to $50 many years ago for the 24cm and considering it has 15 years warranty, feel like this one is the bang for buck pan

    Didn't go with cast iron because of how heavy it is

  • +2

    It's calls forever chemical for any reason. They even made a movie about it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvAOuhyunhY

  • +1

    I have a 26cm scanpan, and it's not big enough for things like bacon and eggs (with tomato and mushroom) or meals for 2 people. So, would recommend larger. I'm also looking for one 28cm or larger.

    • +2

      I have a 28 cm Scanpan stainless frypan. Big but not too big
      Bought it approximately 12 years ago.
      Use it multiple times per week. No indication of wear.
      Great bit of kit.

    • I have a 32cm scanpan ( bought it under $100 ), it's been a few years now. Work like a charm, good enough for 4ppl. Yes I used it on induction stove top as well

  • +1

    The OP has landed on SS,so why(as usual) are other ppl throwing in everything but SS as an option??

    Go the full monty?>
    https://www.ozbargain.com.au/node/904376

  • +1

    I have been using a DeBuyer carbon steel, Lodge cast iron and All-clad stainless pan over the last 7-11 years. Most frequently used is the Lodge cast iron pan. I like that I can stick the stainless pan into the dishwasher though.

    You can get excellent Maillard reaction on steaks on the Stainless - comparable if not better than cast iron. Buying a high quality stainless with solid base should help with more even heat distribution. I cook with natural gas. Lastly, I do have a Scanpan teflon pan which I only occasionally use for making omurice.

    EDIT: https://www.petersofkensington.com.au/cookware-knives/cookwa…
    Wow, I'm sure it cost me around $200 to buy one of these last time I was in the US. I'd say most of the Tefal and Scanpan products with laminated layers/copper layers should be quite good.

    • It's even cheaper overseas. We got a large All-Clad D5 set for just under $2k a few years ago. Was easily one of our top kitchenware purchases that we don't regret a wee bit.

  • +1

    After frying on stainless steel I soak the pan in some water with a drop of dishwashing liquid overnight. Next morning everything comes off very easily. Then it goes in the dishwasher.

    • Similar to you, I usually add water to the still hot pan and put it back on the warm stove to soak. Then hand wash as usual after 30mins. Little bit of elbow grease and it’s good as new no matter how bad it looked earlier.

  • +1

    Do not buy an Aldi one (Crofton). I've got one - it's shit. The bottom is perfectly flat, but on the inside the centre of the pan is domed such that all the liquids drain to the sides and form a ring around the perimeter of the fry pan. Useless.

    • +1

      There is an incredible aldi crofton one with a rippled base and glass lid. No long handle though. I'll post it below. Been looking for another one for yonks,l in casr i ever damage it. amazing if one can pick it up secondhand.

      Stuff doesnt stick. Can chuck it in the oven. Big, 28cm.

      Called "Cook Fry and Serve Pan". Got given it, wish I'd started using it earlier so I couod have grabbed more when in stock.

      • @Embaloo you're in luck. They're back this Wednesday. (Was searching for a review of them and came across your comment)

        • +1

          No way… thanks so much for the heads up. I'm camping out 😆 i'm still using it every day and constantly dishwasing it no issues…
          Looks to be slight difference in handle shape & appearance but hopefully just as good, will assess!

  • +1

    Kitchen Warehouse carry a brand called Wolstead, they are incredible value!

    The Wolstead stainless series pans are made from 18/10 stainless and are dishwasher safe.
    I have a couple of the bigger ones (30cm, 3ply) and a coupe of scanpan axis. I prefer to use the 30cm Wolstead over the scanpan axis as they are not as heavy but have very good heat distribution.

    Btw, when I signed up instore they gave me sign up credit.

    26-28cm, 18/10 stainless
    https://www.kitchenwarehouse.com.au/product/wolstead-steelte…
    https://www.kitchenwarehouse.com.au/product/wolstead-steelte…

    30cm - 3ply, 18/10 stainless
    https://www.kitchenwarehouse.com.au/product/wolstead-superio…

    • I came here to post those

  • +1

    Essteele will be the best option, when on 50 percent off, will cost less than $120, a good reliable brand.

    Amazon commercial pan will also be good choice for $70 and has good reviews.

    • +1

      Purchased a set of Esteele saucepans in 2017. Still going strong and will keep going strong for a long time no doubt. Purchased $165 for set.
      Esteele frypan is good too. It will last forever. Can't remember when this was purchased. A long time ago I'm sure.

    • Tramontina triply also good bang for the buck

      • They are good but expensive here in Australia

  • +1

    Budget - Chef Inox - It's commercial grade cookware - $105 for a 28cm. Better quality than Scanpan/Bacarat/Swiss Diamond etc - big marketing brands. May not look as nice but retain heat better, easy to clean, don't dent as easily.

    Expensive (buy it once/buy it for life or at least 10 years +) - Made In - Expensive and can be hard to find distributors. Looking at $250 for the equivalent pan.

  • +1

    Got the tramontina pan recently after using carbon steel for years. its a game changer, just need to add oil at the right temp and not cook too hot and it'll be non-stick. so easy to clean too!

  • +1

    enamelled cast iron fry pan……..

  • +1

    Go seasoned cast iron OP.

    Aldi usually have cast iron pans on sale in June.

  • +1

    When you finish cooking in the stainless steel pan pour out any fluids then immediately pour cold water on it (dont get splattered). This basically makes whatever is on it loosen via the sudden contraction of the metal. Seriously it will clean off pretty easily. I might use some gumption or pink stuff abrasive paste if I want it to look shop new.

    Also, get one with a steel handle too. We got a baccarat one on sale for $60 from robins kitchen … or was it house? Either way, they always have sales and it'sway cheaper than rrp.

  • I was in exactly the same situation and decided on 2 scanpan pans. It took a 2-3 cooking sessions till I figured out how to stop things sticking but I am very happy with them now. I’ve only cleaned them once with bar keepers friend and they looked brand new again.

  • If you just want to avoid Teflon and other harmful chemicals, have you considered a ceramic non-stick fry pan? They're chemical free and are almost as non-stick as Teflon.

    • i read the user feedbacks/reviews of those tefal ceramics get sticky after a few uses

      • yeah because the non-stickiness is achieved via a coating which is wearing off. There's no such thing as a "non-stick surface" that doesn't have a coating on it.

    • They're chemical free
      avoid Teflon and other harmful chemicals

      My friend, how do you think they achieve this non-stick feature?

    • Bro, water is a chemical

      Ceramic are garbage. I wouldn't want to be ingesting that either. Where does their non stick coating go after several uses?

      They simply stop working

  • Tefal have a 4 set going on Amazon at the moment, paid just over $100 and includes delivery if on Prime.

  • While on this topics, any stainless steel wok and bigger pot recommendation?

    • I have an electric stainless steel wok from sunbeam that I bought from FB marketplace for $50.The only thing is, you can't work on it the way you would do on a traditional wok using their handle, like flipping and tossing action but other than that its pretty much ok.

    • I have a wok stainless steel pan from www.skottsberg.com and it has been my go to for 90% of my cooking lately.

  • As with all OzB's, I have a cast iron pans, Lodge or IKEA or others.

    I love them.

    I also tried stainless steel and I could not get it to not stick, even with oil.

    I think I will stick with cast iron but I know it can be done I have seen it on YT videos.

    • +1

      Clean it while it's still hot is how I manage steel.

    • Stainless steel has a bit of a learning curve, but once you know the temperature you can start at by feel, sight, or your specific hob setting, it's basically nonstick. Also doesn't need seasoning, and can handle soaking, unlike cast iron.

      • +1

        Used to work as a line cook in a commercial kitchen: Stainless steel will always get shit burning and sticking to it unless you use a buttload of fat/oil. The secret to why most restaurant food tastes good is also the reason why they can get away with using stainless steel.

        I'd recommend most home cooks use a nicely seasoned cast iron for most jobs and keep a teflon pan around for the odd time you do really delicate things like crepes or french ommlettes for a perfect, no fuss finish; A little bit of non stick won't kill you any more than a processed sausage will.

    • I’ve never been able to master the not sticking with SS. If you’re cooking burgers or potato patties I find a really thin flexible spatula helps get underneath the food without separating the crispy layer.

  • I got a stainless steel pan from one of the Scanpan deals around here - also do the whole water beading test and my food doesn't stick to the pan itself which is great.

    However I always get burnt grease/marks/stains after cooking and it obviously takes longer to clean (I've been getting out the steel wool/pad and barkeeper's friend to clean it). While it definitely cleans out - what am I doing wrong to always have this issue?

    Is it too much heat or not enough fat?

    • +1

      I used to deal with stainless steels in the offshore/subsea industry.
      The rule was that you could only use stainless steel tools (wire brushes, or steel wool) on stainless steel surfaces.
      If ordinary carbon steel tools were used on stainless steel, you would get particles of iron embedded in the stainless steel surface which would cause surface corrosion and staining.
      So as long as you use stainless steel scouring pads or wire wool pads on your pans, you should be OK.

    • You’re always going fo have some residue, I just give my pan a weekly hit with BKF but other than that it’s always pretty mottled. Ditch the steel wool as you’ll be damaging your pan that way. When you use the BKF you shouldn’t need to scrub hard, for hard spots give it a scrub then come back to it after leaving it for a little to loosen up with the BKF and lots of scrubbing back and forth is more effecting than adding lots of pressure.

    • However I always get burnt grease/marks/stains after cooking and it obviously takes longer to clean (I've been getting out the steel wool/pad and barkeeper's friend to clean it). While it definitely cleans out - what am I doing wrong to always have this issue?

      There's two problems here.

      The first is why you're getting burnt bits on the pan, and the second is how you're cleaning it.

      1) Burnt marks and stains

      You're getting burnt marks because you're heating the pan up too much and letting food burn. There's no rocket science here. Lower the heat, add more oil/liquid. fond is great, cabon is not.

      2) Cleaning

      Put the steel wool away, and don't use metal utensils. You can use these, but you're making it harder to make the pan non-stick with all the micro scratches you're introducing.

      BKF is fine for removing the super fine layer that remains sometimes, but generally the easiest way to remove marks is to add water to the pan and let it boil for 5 minutes. then scrape with a wooden spoon and it'll come right off.

  • Get a le Creuset cast iron/enamel fry pan and abuse it for the better part of 2 decades.

    best use of $200 - less via marketplace.

  • Cheers

  • I got a 8 in Lodge cast iron frypan and a Debuyer 10in carbon steel crepe pan. I don't miss the Nonstick ones anymore.

  • I hope to try a Solidteknics frypan some day if I find a bargain price for it.

    • +1

      I have one and it is ok but they are overpriced for what they are. For half the price you can get a Matfer or Debuyer. I have a Matfer and it is not as pretty as the Solidteknics and the handle is a separate piece of metal to the pan, and the base is thicker and heavier (good or bad depending on your preference). But I find it much easier to maintain a good non-stick seasoning on the Matfer than on the Solidteknics. I wouldn't buy another Solidteknics.

      • Thanks. We have a Debuyer and love it. Will check out matfer.

  • I'm actually super happy with my two Stainless Steel Baccarat pans. They were like $30-$40 each or something, work great on my induction hob. Impressively non-stick if you heat them dry and ensure water beads on the surface before applying oil.

    When I do occasionally end up with a bunch of stuck stuff, Barkeeper's Friend and a Scrub Daddy makes it look good as new with minimal effort; seriously that stuff feels like cheating.

  • Ikea have both cheap and expensive stainless steel pans

  • Mauviel copper frying pan from Williams Sonoma… with lid.

  • https://www.harrisscarfe.com.au/kitchen-dining/cookware/cook…

    I got one of these. Best thing i ever did that day.

  • unless you are a pro chef or something, the Scanpan Impact range is more than sufficient. Have a hunt on amazon and the various kitchen warehouse/Peters of Kensingtons sites for price comparison.
    If you heat them up enough and have some oil/fat when cooking they are non stick. These are my go to SS for frypans and saucepans.

    If you want to go for carbon steel which has better heat retention (but also a bit more finnicky for cleaning and need seasoning) I would recommend buying direct from Darto International - I have a few from them and they are just amazing.

    • I got an Scanpan Impact and a Scanpan commercial at the same time from harris scarfe. They were the same price at the time.

      I couldn't tell you what any physical difference is, but the Commercial is a way better pan.

      Better handle, cooks more evenly, more non stick. Don't ask me how.

  • "Cook, Fry and Serve Pan", Crofton stainless, 28cm, glass & stainless lid, dishwashable, stuff does not stick, wallfe base, amazing for sourdough pancakes, eggs, omlettw, baked stuff that you need to throw in the oven after browning, high sides, induction suitable, can't break it.

    Its a cross between a saucepan and pot, but amazing big size, will never go back and am keeping a lookout for more.

    Anyone have any ideas how to petition aldi to bring certain special buy products back? There's another crofton product i've been hunting for for ages.

    • I agree their "Pro Chef" line is pretty good!

  • IKEA One is pretty decent. Make sure you season it 1st time.

    https://www.ikea.com/au/en/p/ikea-365-frying-pan-stainless-s…

  • I use the scanpan. nothing splash https://www.kitchenwarehouse.com.au/product/scanpan-impact-f… (not sure if it's this size though) and it gets the job done. not the most heavy duty bunt not very heavy and stands up to a lot. going strong after 7 years and expect it to last another 10+

  • I use scanpan 26cm impact frypan, works great on induction and heats faster than using gas. I did accidently burn it once when waiting for it get hot enough, it all came off with a blade scraper. If it was a teflon pan would've had to throw it out.

  • Hi all, so I've finally been scared enough from the barrage of media….

    I've not seen this barrage, so suggest avoiding it!

  • Yep go All-Clad or Go home, don't be such a tight arse

    or you can always get the costco set

Login or Join to leave a comment